Seven Pounds (Gabriele Muccino, 2008)
Category: Sad film about weight and/or currency. Here
is a helpful Venn diagram to show where the film fits in the spectrum of sad
films about weight and currency.
This
is also a sad Will Smith vehicle. Will
Smith is the biggest movie star in the world at the moment, and as such can
star in pretty much any movie he wants to. That he chose to star in this
sadfest to me validates the existence of this blog. Even Will Smith wants to
get his sad on! It’s like when the cool kid in school has the same sneakers as
you do. The blog is nothing if not in with the in crowd.
My familiarity with this issue: As a skinny unemployed man, I’m lacking in both
weight and currency at the moment. I explored this problem on “Deez Poundz,”
the first cut off my failed hip-hop album Dia-Beats.
(By the way, Will Smith don’t gotta cuss in his raps to sell records, and I mean, that’s
cool, good for him.)
I
don’t think Will Smith is a Scientologist, but he may as well be at this point.
He has reached a near-Cruiseian level of weirdness in my book, mainly on the
basis of how he’s pimped out his young children. This trend started way back
with “Just the Two of Us,” and has
continued up to his current effort to have his family take over the world. (At
twelve, Jaden starred in the remake of The
Karate Kid, which I refused to see, and Willow’s burgeoning music career
has included the (s)hit song “Whip My Hair,” released when she was NINE years
old.)
Meanwhile,
Will Smith hasn’t made a movie since this one in 2008. You know, maybe I’m
old-fashioned, but I like it when people have easily-defined roles. Teachers
teach, writers write, movie stars star in movies. No one cares about your kids,
Will. You’re like a mom who keeps posting Facebook status updates about the
cute things that the little one did today. Sure, you’ll get a few pity likes
out of it, but everyone secretly resents you for it.
Most
importantly of all, sister of the blog Lauren Krizel saw this in theaters, and famously
said that this movie was the worst she had ever seen. I’m pretty sure I made
her tell me what happened, because I was sure that I would never see it. Then I
started this blog and here I am. So I kind of know the big twist ending, I
think. We’ll see how much I remember.
Plot summary yoinked from IMDb: “Haunted
by a secret, Ben Thomas looks for redemption by radically transforming the
lives of seven people he doesn't know. Once his plan is set, nothing will be
able to stop him. At least that's what he thinks. But Ben hadn't planned on
falling in love with one of these people and she's the one who will end up
transforming him.”
What I thought of the movie: This
movie made me feel many emotions. Anger, chief among them, but let’s not forget
about rage. I was bewildered, I was uncomfortable, I was hateful (and I think
this movie is about how we should help other people or something like that, but
it clearly didn’t work, because I just want to injure everyone involved with
it). The movie is morbid, and stupid, and manipulative, and it features the
worst ending to a movie I have ever seen. I cannot think of another one that
comes close. In short, Seven Pounds
tried to do a bunch of different things and failed spectacularly at all of
them. In a way, it was perfect.
OK.
Where to begin. (I’m going to SPOIL it throughout the rest of
this post, but if you intend to see this movie and want to remain unspoiled
then I don’t want you to read the blog anymore.) Here we go: the movie stars Jesus
Christ Will Smith as a man on a mysterious quest. This mysterious quest
requires him to be really serious and look sad all the time. And also to be a
huge jerk, and stalk people, and steal his brother’s identity, and I’m getting
ahead of myself.
The
first thing you see in the movie is Will Smith, looking distraught, having just called 911. “There’s been a suicide,” he says. When asked who the victim is, he
replies, “I am.” (Technically incorrect. “There will be a suicide” would have
been more accurate. It's not even ten seconds into the movie and they're improperly conjugating verbs.) He says, in voiceover, “In seven days, God created the
world. In seven seconds, I shattered mine.” (Seven is a motif.)
So
he’s done something bad, and he’s looking for atonement via identity theft,
stalking and eventual possible suicide. That’s your film right there. (His
brother is an IRS agent, and Will steals his identity to find people who might
be “good” and deserving of some mysterious gift that he’s going to give them.) He
has to test them, though (because Jesus said testing people was cool and totally the
thing to do). We see him berate Woody Harrelson (playing, if you can believe it, a blind
vegetarian beef salesman) over the phone to test whether or not he is slow to
anger. After this conversation, he hangs up, gets real upset, destroys a chair, and intensely recites the names of seven (MOTIF) people. This is the second scene in the film.
His
main target is the lovely Rosario Dawson, a woman with congestive heart
failure. He creeps into her hospital room after visiting hours are over, and then sits
in a parked car with the windshield wipers going, which, aside from being as creepy as anything, is a real waste of electricity. Why not switch those wipers
off, Will? You’re just sitting there doing nothing. You’re gonna drain your
battery! (Will Smith’s acting style can best be described as “I really want
people to be impressed by how serious I am in this movie.”)
Rosario
(and others) are (Microsoft Word says that “are” is incorrect here, because the
subject is technically just “Rosario,” but then it would be “Rosario (and
others) is,” which sounds stupid, and this is somehow making me angrier about
this stupid movie), but yes anyway, Rosario (and others) ARE initially creeped
out, but eventually warm to him because… honestly, I don’t know why they do. It
doesn’t make any sense. They do because the script tells them to. At one point, when
they’ve started to forge a romantic bond, Rosario (who does the best that she
can with this tripe) says, smiling, “I don’t really know anything about you or
where you came from, but… you keep showing up.” This is exactly what women say
to people are stalking them as they are dialing 911.
There’s
a lot of other information presented without context. Will has a pet jellyfish.
(I don’t even want to talk about the jellyfish. I’m so terrified of jellyfish.)
Barry Pepper is in it for like five minutes as Will’s friend. I don’t remember
one thing about his character, other than that they had a conversation on a
golf course. (Will just walks right up to him and some woman as they’re
playing, which was also creepy; it reminded me of when Sayid did that in season
four of Lost, when he’s going around
being Ben Linus’s personal hitman.) The movie is reliant on nonstop music to
cue the moods and establish the tension. At one point they play Muse’s cover of
“Feeling Good,” a song that describes the emotional state of exactly no one in
the movie (or watching the movie, for that matter).
OK
let’s just cut to the end. After a confrontation with his brother, who realizes something fishy is up, Will does the do with Rosario, and then chooses that moment (right when Rosario has fallen in love with him) to leave and enact his master plan. And here we learn the
whole point of the movie: Will Smith once was texting while driving and caused
a car accident that killed seven people. In order to atone for this act (for
which he was neither arrested nor served any time, if the movie can be
believed), he has decided that he will donate seven of his organs to seven
people. Organs! Seven of them! (What a motif.) He got the idea for this when he donated a lung lobe to his
cancer-stricken brother. He proceeded on to do four more, apparently (some hockey coach, some child services lady, who cares, we don't really get to know them).
And now for his grand finale, he, of
course, donates his heart to Rosario Dawson, and his eyes to Woody Harrelson. This, of course, requires him to commit the suicide that he claimed had already committed way back when the movie started. To kill himself, he gets in the bathtub with his jellyfish OHMYGOD WHAT.
That is what happens. He dies, the others get the organs, and the movie ends. I don't even know what else to say.
How I related to the movie: For
most of the film, my anger was borne out of the filmmakers’ choice to withhold
vital information: namely, what the hell it is that is happening in the movie.
(I kind of knew, from that three-year-old conversation with my sister, what the
idea was, so I tried to put myself in the mindset of someone who was going in
fresh.) By the end of the film, that anger was replaced by the new anger of
actually knowing what the hell just happened in the movie. To be fair, withholding information is often what telling stories is all about. When it's done well, it's really awesome and satisfying to audiences. But this movie is not artful, it's arbitrary. It does not create suspense, but rather unease, and not the good kind of unease.
And the
worst part is finally knowing what the filmmakers were trying to do, and hating them all
the more for it. Will Smith, as he is in so many of his films, is meant as a
messianic figure, but the questions surrounding his capricious quest are
numerous. They include, is it fair to decide who gets your organs, if they’re
not related to you? If it is, what’s the deal with his random screening
process? Who is he to play God and decide who is “good” enough to receive his
sweet, sweet organs? And above all this is the fact that he’s just a creepy,
overly serious, weird dude who I don’t want to watch for two hours, let alone
two minutes. Ughhh.
How I felt after the movie ended: I don't remember. I think I blacked out or something. Good Lord. The ending of that movie is one of the most ridiculous, tone-deaf, unbelievable,
over-the-top, crazy-as-balls stupid terrible endings I have ever seen. The
protagonist of the film kills himself by sharing a bathtub with his poisonous
pet jellyfish. I want you to read that again. And again.
And then I want you to
think about how I willingly put myself through this. I can stop writing this
blog whenever I want! (Or just watch better sad movies.) It’s my own fault. And
to atone for this, I am going to give seven of you a gift. I hope you guys like
really weak, scrawny, diabetic organs.


Wait. WAAAAAAAAAAAAIT. I have two questions: (1) How does being in a bathtub with a jellyfish kill you? and (2) Does this result in the death of the jellyfish too? Because, dude, that would not be fair. Anyway, thanks for reminding me that I never want to see this movie.
ReplyDeleteThis has to be your best post yet on this blog. I lafted and lafted.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Deleteoh hey, more organ donation movies. shouldn't this be a new tastemysad category? maybe it needs a spoiler alert though. these organ donation movies never seem to be very upfront about the matter.
ReplyDeletewell done
ReplyDeletenew post? i like this blog. it makes me feel better about being the only one laughing in the theatre during a sad movie.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Deletewrite more please!!!!
ReplyDeleteI'm a senior in high school and my health teacher is making us watch this movie because we're covering organ donation. I wish I wasn't serious.
ReplyDeleteYou my friend, are a fucking dickhead. No, you're a cunt. You think this movie is stupid and pathetic? I think you posting about your opinion about this movie is stupid and pathetic. No one actually fucking asked you did they? This movie touched lives, it's one of the saddest movies in history. It is so deep and is quite the movie. I'm sorry if it didn't make it to your preferred movie but frankly no one gives a fuck. It's for people who can relate to this movie. This movie was beautifully done and Will Smith was the perfect actor to portray his character. Don't you dare call this movie shit, you clearly don't know what you're talking about.
ReplyDeleteI am laughing at all of the things you think are important in this movie. I didn't read all of your blog because I had to stop at the wind shield wipers or whatever. You have to think to yourself what state of mind this person was in. When you are dead set on removing yourself from the world, little things like "draining your car battery"... well that shit is POINTLESS lol. It's cool, you've never been there. You've probably lived with a silver spoon in your mouth your whole life. But anyway hey, you're cool, you tried to write a funny review, but uh.. you failed sir. Sorry bro.
ReplyDelete